Bootstrapping India
 Main Page       Feedback? MehtaRahulC@yahoo.com

Why is India facing Kashmir-type terrorism problem, while West does NOT?

    Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Reasons why India is facing Kashmir type insurgency while Western countries DO NOT?
  3. How can citizens of India solve Kashmir problem
  4. Non-solutions to Kashmir problem
  5. Why India has north east type insurgency, while West does NOT?
  6. How can citizens of India solve North East problem
  7. Why India has so much illegal immigration of Bandgleshies, while west does NOT face such problem?
  8. How can citizens of India solve problem of Bangladeshi immigration

Introduction

India is facing several type of terrorist movements
  1. Kashmir : Paskistan, under the active support and instigation of USA/UK and China, is trainning and then sending 1000s of terrorists into Kashmir.

  2. North East : A large number of north east's locals, such as Naga, Manipuri etc, aided by Bangladeshi govt, who is aided and instigated by USA/UK and China, are waging guerilla type war against Indian state.

  3. Not yet, but soon, India will face a seccessionist movement from Bangladeshi immigrants.The fraction of Bangladeshi population has crossed 25%, and anyday anytime, there may be a seccessionist movement to secede from India and may be to join Bangladesh.

  4. Naxalite movement : In some 100-120 districts of India, naxalite movement has wrecked the local administration and economy. [Please click here for my article related to naxalite movement's cuases and solutions].

The Western countries are NOT facing any such threats. Is it due to culture that India is facing so many violent strifes, while West is facing none? Or are the reasons due to administrative differences between West and India? IMO, it is latter --- the reasons are purely administrative. And by making certain changes in administration, the citizens of India can fix those flaws.


Reasons why India is facing Kashmir type insurgency while Western countries DO NOT?

Due to active material/logistic support and instigation of US/UK and China, Pakistan is trainning and sending 1000s of terrorists into Kashmir, and creating a heavoc.

The reason why India cannot stop it are :
  1. India's intellectuals/mediamen are spineless --- none has spine to call a spade a spade, and label US/UK and China as enemies of India. Kashmir is a war NOT between India and Pak, but a proxy-war between India and US/UK/China, where Pak is just a proxy of US/UK/China. There is one reason why media-owners DO NOT write about role US/UK in instigating Pakistan against India --- as of today, media-owners' heavily depend on US/UK-based companies for advertisement revenue. As a result, media-owners are scared of writing anything that would upset US/UK's business and political elite. And since correct characterization of problem does NOT appear in academic circles, and media, the correct forumulation of strategy does NOT emerge eighter.

  2. Given the weak economy and military of India (weak compared to US/UK), India is NOT in a position to deter US/UK and China from providing material etc help to Pakistan. If Pakistan is alone, India can easily force Pakistan and its elite to stop and NOT provide any help to terrorists. But as long as Pakistan is aided by US/UK, India is NOT in a position to stop Pak.

  3. Given the proximity to LoC (Line of Control) and terrain, the terrorists conduct some disruptive operation, and easily escape before the policemen or soldiers get time to strike back.

  4. Much of the Indian population is unarmed, thanks to defunct leaders/intellectuals who have made laws that outlaws possessing arms. The terrorists are always armed to teeth, as they dont follow the law banning weapons anyway, while commons are unarmed. So terrorists peacefully kill as many as they want, and escape. The policemen/soldiers are armed, but its too late before they come. In US, a large number of citizens, perticularly in remote and far-out areas are armed. So if terrorists were to stike, they too would lose heavily.

The US and other Western countries are powerful enough that no country would offer economic/military assistance to any country or group of individual that would decide to create such an insurgency in US. Therefore, US and West are NOT facing any such violent insurgencies. China too has an economy/military that would deter other countries from helping seccessionists in China.


How can citizens of India solve Kashmir problem

The citizens of India will need to FORCE US/UK that it would stop helping Pakistan. How? Only some realistic threats would work. As of today, India is offering more and more appeasements to US/UK with the hope that US/UK would stop helping Pakistan, but these appeasements will NOT help --- instead it would only convince US/UK that India is a weak nation, and they would step up the help. As of today, Indian polity and intelligentia is sold out, and it would stand errect before US/UK's demands. Then what can/should citizens of India do?

  1. Steps 1-3: The citizens should force MLAs, MPs and District Panchayat Members to create procedures that would enable citizens to pass laws in District Panchayats, Assemblies and Parliament. Please read LM.01 to see the procedure using which citizens can pass laws in District Panchayats and City Councils. Please read LM.02 to see the procedure using which citizens can pass laws in Assembly. And please read LM.03 to see the procedure using which citizens can pass laws in Parliament.

  2. Steps 4-19 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures CT.01-16. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would improve police, courts and regulation. This will enable citizens to start, run and wind-up industries at a much faster pace.

  3. Steps 20-34 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures EAS.01-15. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would reduce poverty and strenghten economy.

  4. Steps 35-38 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures ID.01-04. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would improve tracking of individuals and properties for crime and taxation purposes.

  5. Step 39 : The citizens of India, using LM.03 should legalize possessing arms. Once the citizenry is armed, it would deter terrorists from attacking them.

  6. Steps 40-44 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures TX.01-05. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would tax collection, and reduce regressiveness in tax collection, which would further increase economic growth.

  7. Steps 45-47 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures RWE.01-03. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would reduce wasteful expenditure.

With above steps, India will be able to develop an economy and military that would match economy and military of US. Once that happens India would be able to issue REALISTIC threats to US, UK and China that would stop them from assisting Pakistan. eg once Indian economy/military matches that of US, India can issue a realistic threat of supplying nuclear weapons to Cuba/Mexico if US were to continue its help to Pakistan. Likewise, India can also threaten UK of providing nuclear help to Ireland if UK were to continue its support to Pakistan, and Indian can realistically threaten to provide nuclear help to Taiwan if Chian were to offer help to Pakistan. These threats, and some actual nuclear assistance, if threats are taken lightly, will be sufficient to deter China, UK and US from helping Pakistan.

Once India has strong economic/military, and US/UK and China stop helping Pakistan, India can easily threaten Pakistan's leaders, senior officers and elitemen of violent consequences, at personal as well as national level, if Pakistan send terrorists into Kasmir or anywhere else in India. This threat, followed by some examples, will be sufficient to deter Pakistan for good. And Kashmir problem will be solved.


Non-solutions to Kashmir problem

It is futile, and utter waste of time and hopes to initiate a dialog with Pakistan. Pakistan is a defunct state, and Pakistani polity/elite is a stooge of US and UK. The polity, military elite and economic elite of Pakistan will do exactly what US's elite dictates them to do. Our words will fall on deaf ears.

Talking to US/UK will also be useless, unless we have economy/military that matches US. Till then US will (unfortunately, but rightly) see us as a weak state, and will ONLY think of confiscating our natural resources, and NOT think of stopping military etc help Pakistan.

IOW, we should STOP all freindly and remedial dialogues with US, UK, Pakistan etc on Kasmir issue. We should focus on improving our courts, tax system, administration etc so that our economy/military becomes as strong as that of US.


Why India has north east type insurgency, while West does NOT?

Insurgencies in Asam, Nagaland, Manipur etc are due to some internal reasons, and some external reasons.

The main external reason is : US/UK and China provide logistic support and instigation to Bangladesh to provide bases to terrorists; and due to support, trainning and bases, India's policemen and soldiers are having difficult time in suppressing them.

And the main internal reason is : due to rampant corruption in policemen, officers, Ministers and judges (lower courts as well as High Court) in the northeast, the commons of north east have faced too much economic injustice and physical atrocities; these injustices and atrocities have turned the local population against the Indian state.

As usual, India's intellectuals have shown their spinelessness, and written NOTHING about support that US/UK and China provides to terrorists in North East. The reasons are obvious --- the usual spinelessness and financial dependence of media's owners on US/UK based companies.

Given the weak economy and military of India (weak compared to US/UK), India is NOT in a position to deter US/UK and China from providing material etc help to Bangladesh. If Bangladesh is alone, India can easily force Bangladesh and its elite to stop and NOT provide any help to NE-terrorists. But as long as Bangladesh is aided by US/UK, India is NOT in a position to stop Pak.

The US and other Western countries are powerful enough that no country would offer economic/military assistance to any country or group of individual that would decide to create such an insurgency in US. Therefore, US and West are NOT facing any such violent insurgencies. China too has an economy/military that would deter other countries from helping seccessionists in China.


How can citizens of India solve North East problem

The citizens of India will need to FORCE US/UK that it would stop helping Bagladesh. How? I explained above. In addition, the citizens of India also need to fix

  1. Steps 1-3: The citizens should force MLAs, MPs and District Panchayat Members to create procedures that would enable citizens to pass laws in District Panchayats, Assemblies and Parliament. Please read LM.01 to see the procedure using which citizens can pass laws in District Panchayats and City Councils. Please read LM.02 to see the procedure using which citizens can pass laws in Assembly. And please read LM.03 to see the procedure using which citizens can pass laws in Parliament.

  2. Steps 4-19 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures CT.01-16. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would improve police, courts and regulation. This will enable citizens to start, run and wind-up industries at a much faster pace.

  3. Steps 20-34 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures EAS.01-15. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would reduce poverty and strenghten economy.

  4. Steps 35-38 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures ID.01-04. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would improve tracking of individuals and properties for crime and taxation purposes.

  5. Step 39 : The citizens of India, using LM.03 should legalize possessing arms. Once the citizenry is armed, it would deter terrorists from attacking them.

  6. Steps 40-44 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures TX.01-05. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would tax collection, and reduce regressiveness in tax collection, which would further increase economic growth.

  7. Steps 45-47 : The citizens of India, using LM.01-03 should pass drafts to enact procedures RWE.01-03. For list of this procedures and link to details, please click here). These procedures would reduce wasteful expenditure.

With above steps, India will be able to develop an economy and military that would match economy and military of US. Once that happens India would be able to issue REALISTIC threats to US, UK and China that would stop them from assisting Pakistan. This will solve the problem of NE-insurgency.

Also, steps4-19 would also improve police, administration and reduce atrocidty and injustice in North East. This will also reduce the alienation of the local people from the India state and thus reduce the strength of the sessionists.


Why India has so much illegal immigration of Bandgleshies, while west does NOT face such problem?

Apart from insurgencies in Asam, Nagaland, Manipur etc, we are facing one more problem in North East : The population of Bangladeshi illegal immigrants is rising day-by-day. It has already crossed 20% in staes like Asam and Tripura, and it may reach 35% within 15-20 years and may even cross 50% within 350-40 years. As their fraction increases, their is a real possibility of Bangladeshies starting a sessionist movement to secede from India and may even join Bangladesh.

As of today, there is NO militant movement against the state from the local illegal immigrants. But near the border areas, the gangs of illegal immigrants, with explicit support from other immigrants, have already started using violence against non-bangladeshi locals to force them to flee and grab their land. And as usual, due to rampant corruption in policemen and judges, they manage to get away. As this land grabbing increases, there is a real possibility that the areas near border will become 100% Bangladeshi, and threat of seccession will become real.

How come West does NOT face this problem? I have discussed this in "why India faces problem of illegal immigration, while West faces to a lesser extent". Please click here for details.


Why can citizens of India solve the problem of illegal immigration?

I have discussed this in "why India faces problem of illegal immigration, while West faces to a lesser extent". Please click here for details.


If you have any other question, please mail it to MehtaRahulC@yahoo.com. Thousand thanks in advance.