The MRCM (Mine Rent for Citizens and Military) Party
Jai Jawan Jai Kisan
Main Page     Feedback? MehtaRahulC@yahoo.com      Orkut Community For Discussions

Brief    descriptions    of    first    seven changes
Contents
  1. First modification : giving higher preference to more backward
  2. Second modification : the system of economic-choice , social choice
  3. Other steps to reduce demand for reservation
  4. Over all stand on reservation
  5. Details of administrative changes we promise on reservation issue
  6. Some rough idea of economic choice
  7. Against some anti-reservationists, who are hypocrites
  8. Against some pro-reservationists, who are also hypocrites


1.    First modification : giving higher preference to more backward

         The communities which have lesser representation in administration will get more seats till their representation is at the same level. For this we need a complete caste census and details are given later.


2.    Second modification : the system of economic-choice , social choice

         What makes us different from all parties is that we support an administrative system, called as economic-preference as opposed to social preference to reduce demand for reservation in SC, ST and OBCs. Following is the summary of the system of second-choice for Dalits, OBCs
  1. Any member of a sub-caste that belongs to ST, SC or OBC can walk to Tahsildar’s office, undergo verification and apply for economic-choice , where in
    • he shall still retain his SC, ST, OBC status
    • he shall receive inflation adjusted Rs 100 per month, till he cancels economic-choice
    • he will be eligible for reservation moment he cancels his economic-choice
    • the number of reserved seats will decrease by 50% of those who opt for economic-choice
    • the money shall come from tax on commercial , residential, industrial land and nowhere else
  2. Example : India has 100 cr of population of which 14% i.e. 14 cr are SC. So if a college has 1000 seats of then 140 are reserved . Now suppose out of these 14 cr SCs, say 6 cr insist on economic-choice then each shall get payment of Rs 100 a month and reservation for SC will go down by 14*0.66*6/14 = 3.9% i.e. will become about 9.1%.
         Most poor Dalits did not get much benefit from Reservation, and as elite in Dalits increases in size, the opportunities for poor dalits further reduces. The economic-choice creates a system by which the poor left out dalits can also get benefit of the reservation as well. Many of them would opt for economic-choice as (opposed to social-choice that reservation offers). This will reduce reservation


3.    Other steps to reduce demand for reservation

  1. Reducing casteism in courts : The demand for reservation is high, as there is intense nepotism , casteism in courts. Due to rampant nepotism , casteism, commons of Dalits , OBCs also feel desire to have “their own” men in courts etc. The laws we have proposed to improve courts reduce casteism , nepotism in courts and will thus reduce the demand for reservation in Dalits, OBCs etc. The decrease in corruption in courts will also decrease demand in Dalit, OBC youth to become judges.
  2. Reducing corruption, atrocities in police : The demand for reservation is high, as there is intense corruption and atrocities in policemen. Due to rampant corruption and high handedness, members Dalits and OBCs also feel desire to have “their own” men in police etc. The laws we have proposed to improve police reduce corruption in police as well as atrocities. This will reduce the demand for caste based reservation in Dalits, OBCs etc. The decrease in corruption in courts will also decrease demand in Dalit, OBC youth to become policemen and will reduce intensity of demand for caste based reservation in police.
  3. Reducing corruption in administration : Due to rampant corruption and high handedness, members Dalits and OBCs also feel desire to have “their own” men in administration etc. The laws we have proposed to improve police reduce corruption and arbitrariness in administration. This will reduce the demand for caste based reservation in Dalits, OBCs etc. This will also decrease desire in educated. The decrease in corruption in courts will also decrease demand in Dalit, OBC youth to become policemen and will reduce intensity of demand for caste based reservation in police.
  4. English education : The education in English is lower in Dalit, OBCs due to upper caste intellectuals’ decision to discourage English education in Govt schools as far as possible. Many upper caste who were well off sent their kids to English schools or other local language schools, but at least English was taught properly. As a result, OBC, Dalits get less score in many subjects where preparation material is English. Once universal English education is implemented, the scores of Dalits, OBCs will reduce and this will reduce demand for reservation.


4.    Over all stand on reservation

         MRCM’s forth demand-cum-promise will substantially reduce poverty. And the changes we propose in education will further reduce poverty and economic gap between dalits and upper castes. And the changes we propose in religious charities will reduce the discrimination they face in temples, and with that social discrimination shall also reduce. We demand and promise to end ALL interviews at the level of initial recruitment in Police, Govt, banks, RBI, SBI, judiciary, Govt lawyer and so forth, and this will also reduce the discrimination Dalits face in recruitment. So the % score gap between closing rank general and reserved categories would reduce day by day.
         But as of now, we support Caste based Reservation. We believe in reducing the strife by increasing education in dalits so that % gap in closing rank decreases, and by reducing demand for reservation in dalits using the proposed system of economic-choice.
         In addition, we propose following modification in reservation
  1. No reservation for Dalits, Tribals and OBCs who are not Hindu, Buddhists or Sikh. To be specific, no reservation for Dalits, Tribals, OBCs in Muslims, Christians etc.
  2. The Dalit, Tribal or OBC if applicable for reservation, will have to first apply in their respective quota and only after their quota is filled, can they apply in general quota
  3. No reservation on any other basis, including religion, economic or social
  4. Create a system of economic-choice to reduce demand for reservation
  5. Ensure that backward amongst backward get benefits using sub-quota or other means
         These are our broad proposals. Devil lies in details. The next section gives details.


5.    Details of administrative changes we promise on reservation issue

Economic-Choice System
  1. Any member of a sub-caste that belongs to ST, SC or OBC can walk to Tahsildar’s office, undergo verification and apply for economic-choice , where in
    • he shall still retain his SC, ST, OBC status
    • he shall receive inflation adjusted Rs 150 per month, till he cancels economic-choice
    • till he gets this payment, he cannot apply in reserved quota.
    • he will be eligible for reservation the day he cancels his second-choice
    • the number of reserved seats will decrease depending on number of those who have opted-out
    • the money shall come from tax on commercial , residential, industrial land and nowhere else.
  2. Example : India has 100 cr of population of which 14% i.e. 14 cr are SC. So if a college has 1000 seats of then 140 are reserved . Now suppose out of these 14 cr SCs, say 6 cr insist on economic-choice then each shall get payment of Rs 100 a month and reservation for SC will go down by 14*0.66*6/14 = 5.94% i.e. will become 8.06% IOW, if every SC were to take economic choice, the reservation would become 1/3 of what it is now. The reservation will be across ran and file of administration, from Supreme Court to peons
  3. If a person has opted for economic-choice and then changes to social-choice, he will be entitled for CBR benefits on that day. But if he reverts back to economic choice, he shall get Rs 100/mo payment after 6 months
  4. If a person is Dalit, OBC has opted for economic-choice, he can still obtain seat on quota, but shall become eligible after he cancels economic-choice
  5. If a person has taken any seat on SC/ST or OBC quota, he will not be eligible for economic-choice
  6. The Rs 100/mo payment will come for a child below 18 only if both parents opt for economic-choice
  7. If both parents have opted for economic-choice, their children shall get Rs 200/mo for at most (2 sons) or (2 sons, 1 daughter).
Caste census
  1. Conduct a full wealth and sub-caste census : Caste strife is a reality. It cannot vanish by hiding it and it cant be dealt administratively if it is hidden. To properly deal with any issue, administration needs crystal clear information. So we propose to take sub-caste census where in sub-caste of each person along with position he holds in Govt, PSU and market value of land/assets he owns will be noted. The census will improve with National-ID system and an accurate system with less than 1% inaccuracy can be built in 2-4 years. But an approximate system can be built in 6 months. We shall start with the inaccurate system and increase the accuracy every day.
  2. There are about 200 sub-castes in India, but since social situation between a caste in one state and analogous caste in another state may be different, they become different caste in the National list. So the National List has about 5000 castes, while most States’ Lists have about 200-400 sub-castes. So the census will note which of the 5000 state-wise sub-caste the person belongs to. Please note – sub-castes will be state-wise only.
  3. If a person claims to general, then he need not specify caste or sub-caste and shall not get any benefit of reservation. But if a person or his father has taken benefit of reservation, then he must specify the caste, state and sub-caste he belongs to.
  4. Using person-caste-wealth data, PM can obtain per capita wealth of sub-caste.
  5. Political Wellness Index : The Political Index of a caste will be calculated as follows

    Position Points
    PM, Supreme Court judge, HC-Cj, Regulators in Central Govt , RBI Gov, RBI Deputy Gov, Bank Chairman 50,00,000 points
    High Court judges, Principal Session judges, Dept Secretaries in Central Govt, regulators in State Govt, CM 40,00,000 points
    Sessions judges, Ministers in Center 10,00,000 points
    Other lower court judges, Ministers in State 5,00,000 points
    MP, officers above Under Secretaries 1,00,000 points
    MLA , District Panchayat Sarpanch 15,000 points
    All class-I officers in Central, State Govt, Police etc (not PSUs) 20,000 points
    All class-II officers in Central, State Govt, Police , etc 10,000 points
    All class-III officers in Central, State Govt, Police etc 5,000 points
    All employees in PSUs, Central Govt, State Govt etc (including above) Annual Basic Salary divided by 100
    Person with 10,00,000 times the per capita wealth 100,00,000 points
    Person with 1,00,000 times the per capita wealth 10,00,000 points
    Person with 10,000 times the per capita wealth 1,00,000 points
    Person with 1000 times the per capita wealth 10,000 points
    Person with 100 times the per capita wealth 1,000 points

Policies to assist backward amongst backward
  1. The castes with lower points would get more seats within their quota.

         The details will be provided on this webpage later.



6.    Some rough idea of economic choice

         Hypothetically, if entire 60cr of SC, ST and OBC population were to go on economic choice, then the quota would reduce from 50% to 50%/4 = about 12.5% and costs will be Rs 1200 * 60 = Rs 72,000cr a year. But that is an extreme scenario.


7.    Against some anti-reservationists, who are hypocrites

         We oppose the upper caste anti-reservation activists who oppose reservation on the basis of merit, and then shamelessly support laws that promote nepotism in judge, promote self finance colleges where merit is not even asked for and promote interview system which upper caste have been using to filter out dalits. We strongly and intensely hate the intellectuals and activists who have supported pro-nepotism , anti-Dalit laws and then opposed reservation by using excuse of merit. IMO, they are hypocrites not worth talking to. We are open to debate on reservation and explain why we support reservation, but with only those adversaries who can give in writing that they oppose the following laws 1. judge shall appoint judges. 2. judges shall give judgments and not Jurors 3. interviews in judiciary and administration.


8.    Against some pro-reservationists, who are also hypocrites

         There are those who oppose reservation, and support nepotism in courts and administration. I call them anti-reservation hypocrites. And then there are those elite SC, ST and OBCs who insist on en-cashing on the plight of poor OBCs, SCs, STs etc . We oppose hypocrites of this categories as well.


Main Page     Feedback? MehtaRahulC@yahoo.com      Orkut Community For Discussions